Future of Euro Currency - France Leaving Euro - Romania Protests

66

By billyaustindillon

Euro and European Carry Trade Selling

Euro breakup threats with France and Romanian protests has prompted Euro carry trade selling. The rot continues with French Euro threats, Romanian protests, Euro and European carry trades selling at week’s end. We have seen the European trillion dollar emergency fund, the British coalition government in power and Spanish austerity plans all unveiled yet it seem all of Europe is unraveling here. after the market have digested As of early this morning, all of Europe is plunging, The at Euro at 2008 lows with a 1.2400 handle, sterling testing 1.45 against the dollar and the central European carry trades the Polish Zloty and Hungarian Forint off over 1.5%.

It is not just the being hit, but non EMU currencies being sold off also. The “wolf pack” smells blood with, Spanish unions announcing a public service strike yesterday, Greece striking again and talks of the French threatening to leave the Euro. Emerging Europe is also being squeezed, Romania is slashing government budgets by 25%, and pensions by 15% which has led to protests also. The big winners are precious metals with Gold threatening $1,250 and all time highs as we see Euro and European carry trades battered.

France Threatens to Leave Euro
France Threatens to Leave Euro

Romanian Protests

As the world focuses on the core European countries emerging Europe faces problems of its own as Euro and European carry trade selling picks up. The Polish zloty has fallen 1.1 percent against the euro from Friday's open, the euro traded at 4.0030 zlotys. The US dollar broke the key EURUSD $1.25 level. Bucharest stocks were the worst hit, falling around 2 percent. Stock markets in Warsaw, Moscow, Prague and Budapest fell around one percent Earlier in Asia, Indian and Chinese markets closed half a percent lower.

Desperate situations call for drastic actions. Something the U.S. and other countries have not remotely considered yet. Romania announced it will cut civil servants salaries by 25 per cent and that all pensions will be cut by 15 per cent on June 1. Romanian national statistics show the average pension is 734 lei (223 dollars), with the minimum pension 350 lei (106 dollars).

In the Romanian capital Bucharest, the east Romanian city of Galati and the northern Romanian city of Iasi on Wednesday several thousand pensioners demonstrated against the proposed austerity measures. There were minor fights between angry pensioners and police with a few pensioners having to be hospitalized.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) Romanian officials last week agreed on drastic new austerity measures and structural reforms. Romania will receive a 20-billion-euro (25-billion-dollar) emergency loan from the IMF, European Union and World Bank. Romania has already received 12 billion Euros, but the crisis continues to worsen. Expects similar in Greece and the PIIGS should they access emergency funding. For those worried about central Government the IMF has linked the new austerity measures to the disbursement of the loan's fifth installment of 850 million Euros in June.

I have little doubt that we will see more signs that the Greek contagion is only just starting to affect reality and more events like Spain and Romania are on the cards. From a positive point of view this is better sooner rather than later. For Europe to spin around growth needs to not be bludgeoned to more worrying levels. Europe needs to maintain low interest rates or countries will be in danger of default.

France Threatens to Leave Euro

Sure this story may be a lot of hot air, something French president Sarkozy is not immune from but it provides kindling for the Euro fire sale. Spanish newspaper El País reports that Sarkozy threatened at the Brussels summit of EU leaders last Friday 'a compromise from everyone to support Greece ... or France would reconsider its position in the euro'.

El Pais quotes Spanish Prime Minister José Luis Rodriguez Zapatero after. Zapatero revealed the French threat at a closed-doors meeting of his Spanish socialist party on Wednesday. The paper reports "Sarkozy went as far as banging his fist on the table and threatening to leave the euro," said one unnamed Socialist leader who was at the meeting with Zapatero. "That obliged Angela Merkel to bend and reach an agreement."

In confirmation of the different sides drawn in Europe a different source from the Zapatero meeting told El País that "France, Italy and Spain formed a common front against German and Sarkozy threatened Merkel with a break in the traditional Franco-German axis."

El País also quotes Sarkozy saying "if at time like this, with all that is happening, Europe is not capable of a united response, then the euro makes no sense". Comments like this only help see Euro and European carry trades battered. Whether true or not they help the markets justify short bond and currency positions. Euro and European carry trade selling needs some positive news to reverse the trend. History suggests the ECB will let the market get short and try and catch the wolf pack short and draw blood. Keep that in mind on any contrarian investments and trades.

ECB Intervention

A week into it and there is no respite from the Euro contagion. One suspects this will become a battle between the trading wolf packs (my new favorite term) and the ECB and its buddies. What markets will watch for is ECB intervention in the currency markets. Keep in mind that a weaker Euro is better for European exporters, think Germany and France.

Let us look at the extreme case of the euro at parity to the dollar, it is plausible given it has been near .80, and the high was over 1.60. At parity the PIIGS all become low-cost producers within Europe. Germany, Scandinavia and France become low-cost producers for high value-added exports and Germany and core Europe sees higher growth than expected. So who truly wins out of a lower Euro?

What Europe must do is paint a picture of a solid Europe with austerity programs that will leave Europe structurally stronger. What the ECB does not want to see is a currency declining due to structural fears. A currency declining due to excess liquidity, as the USD was until the PIIGS starting rolling over, is not a difficult fix.

This brings us back to the intervention question, what the ECB wants is austerity but not to the point that all economic growth is choked off this then suggests a lower Euro. The appropriate question than is does Europe want lower yields or a strong Euro at the moment. If the ECB accesses the swap line they will be reducing Euro liquidity as they increase USD liquidity by buying EUR/USD. Thus Euro bond yields would be pressured higher, meaning the ECB would have to intervene there also which they probably would not one to do. What the ECB wants is orderly markets and any intervention will be along those lines.

Comments on Euro and European Carry Trade Selling

katiem2 profile image

katiem2 2 years ago

What a great topic! You just keep coming up with such great and informative stuff. I'm interested in all things European thanks for keeping us in the know! Peace :)

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Thanks for your feedback Katie. Europe is getting more interesting by the minute and is so entwined with the US, whether we want to admit it or not. Oil and the S&P were smacked today, why? European events. I am just trying to stay ahead of the curve so to speak.

Philip Cooper 2 years ago

Well done Billy....nice hub. As you know I'm in Greece and it might interest you to know that yesterday the Greek authorities in their drive to stamp out tax evasion caught 159 doctors in one area of athens that owed 31 million euro in non -declared taxes. The latest figures suggest that Greek tax evaders owe the government 6 billion euros or 2.1% of GDP.

Merlin Fraser profile image

Merlin Fraser 2 years ago

Thanks Billy,

Yet another great and informative hub and a subject I follow with a certain amount of "I told you So" about it.

I was and never have been a fan of the Euro, it was always too close to being a political currency for my liking and was more than happy when the UK managed to stay out.

Trouble is it has far too much clout on the world stage to be ignored and in today's electronic "pass the parcel" where all it needs is for someone in the Euro zone to sneeze and the rest of the world reaches for the tissues.

As most people who know me know I have little love for the committee structure of control, the bigger the committee the bigger the compromise required to get a decision.

And to me Europe is under the control ( for want of a better word) of the biggest and most compromised committee in the world.

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Good to hear from you Philip and thanks for the update. That is the type of thing that Greece must do if they are to achieve their austerity targets. The anger of a public being expected to bear the brunt of the cutbacks in a nation where it seems politicians and the wealthy have prospered at their expense. The government must act to get everyone in it together. If no then default is the option left.

msorensson profile image

msorensson Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

Brilliant presentation of information, Billy.

Thanks!!

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Merlin well put - I am in agreement I never thought the Euro was appropriate given the different economics, cultures and debts of all member nations. While it is good in theory as a currency to take on the dollar the fact is the EMU snake was difficult at best. Recall the attack on the Lire and Franc back in the day. I think what is clear is there are countries that the Euro works well for, those that are already within the guidelines. However the idea was to bring the weaker economies up instead it threatens to bring the strong down. Really though they let the banks get out of hand and they should have to pay for their thievery but just like the US they are getting off. Then to hear Sarkozy threatens to pull out of the Euro is a bit rich given the main banks being bailed out are French lending to Greece! How much of that is just Spanish Socialist versus French Right Wing we will never know but as they say where there is Gaulist Smoke there is Fire! That in itself shows you we have a political currency indeed.

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Thank you Melinda - I am glad you enjoyed it. I wish there was some positive goings on in Europe to write about :(

msorensson profile image

msorensson Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

Actually, Billy..I was just in a conference the other day..There is..but in a privately held enclave.

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Melinda yes this is true there are always pockets - the negatives are really the PIIGs and the Banksters and how it is affecting the peripheries. On the positive the debt markets did need to have the froth taken off. It should never have been aloud to get this way and that is what the Banksters allowed for their own greed.

msorensson profile image

msorensson Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

I agree, Billy. Great insight.

I don't know if you read this but thought I would post it here. This is what happens when we equate personal power with money.

http://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/europe/05/14/russia.

DustinsMom profile image

DustinsMom 2 years ago

Great informative hub.

breakfastpop profile image

breakfastpop Level 8 Commenter 2 years ago

Thanks for this informative hub. I am always feel smarter after reading your work.

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Thanks for your feedback DustinsMom

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Thanks Pop for your positive feedback, I appreciate it.

CYBERSUPE profile image

CYBERSUPE 2 years ago

One loaded hub---does the French wanting to leave the Euro surprise you ? Thank you for keeping me posted on the world economy

billyaustindillon profile image

billyaustindillon Hub Author 2 years ago

Cybersupe on the French wanting to leave yes and no - I thought if anyone leaves it will be the Germans first as going back to the DM would be an easy option when everyone is expecting them to take other's debt on. However the French had the most to lose other than the PIIGS themselves given the French bank loans to Greece. France has also been a problem child with agricultural subsidies etc. Euro has seen 4 year loses to 1.2316 so this problem isn't getting any relief yet.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working